By now we have all heard the term nostalgia described as “the pain from an old wound”. Even though this is inaccurate, it is my favorite definition of the word. Proust, maybe better than anyone, understood this when he wrote “In Search of Lost Time”. It is said that there is no human emotion that Shakespeare did not write about, but that is a lie. He may have written dozens of sonnets about unrequited love, but The Bard never wrote one about reciprocated hatred, combined with the most powerful need…
It is with this in mind that I sit down to write the story of Amanda and me. I have known her now for almost a quarter of a century, and she and I have been intimate, off and on, for close to a decade and a half. In all this time, nothing she has ever done, even one time, has ever led me to believe that she has the smallest bit of affection for me. And yet, every now and again, her life will crash over mine, like a massive wave over a solid cliff face on the shore, eroding it, destroying it slowly, and shaping it at the same time.
It is with no hesitation that I can say I am the man I am today, in no small part, because of the way she has eroded me, and the way I have tried to heal myself.
There are three questions I have to ask myself
The first is if I love her, and the answer is a decided “no”. That much, at least I can see clearly. I did love her once, more so than the air I took into my lungs. But not now.
You can’t love something that has no soul, because something that has no soul is not a person.
The second is what is she to me now? I’m not sure what she is, at all, let alone who she is to me.
The third is the most troubling. I have to ask myself, over and over why she and I are drawn to each other. And this is the question I am most unsure about. Certainly sex has something to do with it. That is always a central focus of our relationship. But not all of it. There is more. It’s like trying to climb a mountain that no one can climb, or stop the movement of the tides with one bare hand.
It just is what it is, and there are no real answers.
In college I took her to dinner. This is after she had cheated on me, and left me for another man, and then come back. It was winterfall, and very pleasant in Louisiana. I took her to a secluded restaurant, no longer open, and we ate on the patio. Emotions with Amanda ran passionately hot, and completely nonexistent with no space in between. That night was a nonexistent night. She ate her food like it was made of cardboard, and never spoke a word. In jest I laughed, and called her “My little wooden girl”, when I couldn’t get any response from her.
She moved faster than I have ever seen anyone move in my life. She stabbed me in the shoulder with her fork. She sat back down and smiled, and went back to eating.
I yelled and I screamed and I flung myself around that patio like an insane bull knocking over everything in my path. She never reacted to it. She just sat there, calmly, eating her risotto with the same fork she had stabbed me with, not even paying attention to the drama I was providing.
When the waiters came outside and threated to call the police, she wiped her mouth, picked up her purse and went to sit in my car.
That night, she told me she loved me, that she should have never cheated on me, that she had been a fool. She whispered sweet, loving things in my ear and made passionate love to me.
10 years later, she has never apologized for stabbing me.
I don’t mean that she has never said the words, although she hasn’t. I mean she has never felt sorry for even a moment for what she did. Honestly I don’t think she has ever felt sorry for anything she has ever done. The truth is that she may never have felt the same emotions you and I feel every day. I will never know.
That lack of emotion, that complete absence of pity, is what presents the challenge. It’s like if I can just get her to feel something, anything, I’ll know she is capable of it. Until the day I know she is capable of emotion, I am afraid that she is capable of absolutely anything.
It’s been two years, more or less, since the last time the waves crashed, and it’s time again.
Last night I saw her again. She was in the same restaurant I was in, and let me tell you, she looked good. She’s a very petite brunet with gray, intense, creepy eyes. She was there with a girl friend and her 4 year old daughter. I was there with the pastor from my church. She couldn’t keep her eyes off of me, and as much as I tried to suppress it, the challenge was there from her: dominate me, possess me, tame me. Of course none of those things are possible.
On my way out the door, I passed her table and wordlessly tossed my business card onto her plate.
Now I know she picked it up. I feel sure that she is going to contact me. She always does; she is as powerless to resist me as I am to resist her.
So in the time I have left I am going to rip it all open. I am going to tell the story and maybe, by the end of it, I can know why I feel what I feel. Maybe by making the old wound ache, I can avoid letting it cripple me this time around.
At the very least, there will be a record if I go missing.